Outgrowth Investing

Red Day

A way to look at a bad day that keeps the fear from making your decisions. About five minutes. Everything you type stays in this browser: nothing is sent anywhere, and there's no account.

Start here

You're not broken.

Most advice says check your stocks once a quarter and ignore the rest. That sounds wise, and almost nobody does it. People look anyway, and then feel guilty on top of scared.

This doesn't ask you to stop looking. It gives you a way to look.

Why drops hit so hard

Losses hurt about twice as much as gains feel good. Kahneman and Tversky found that losing $1,000 feels roughly twice as bad as gaining $1,000 feels good. That's built into almost everyone. It isn't a flaw in you.

The more often you look, the more losses you see. Over long stretches the US market has been up on a little more than half of all trading days, but in roughly three out of four calendar years. Same market, very different experience:

If you checkYou see a lossIt feels like
Every dayAlmost every other dayConstant bad news, even in a good year
Every monthAbout one month in threeFrequent worry
Every yearAbout one year in fourMostly progress

Benartzi and Thaler called this myopic loss aversion: people who look more often feel more losses, and tend to make more fearful decisions. Sources: Kahneman & Tversky (1979), Econometrica; Benartzi & Thaler (1995), Quarterly Journal of Economics.

Step 1

Is it the market, or your stock?

Open your broker and read two numbers off the screen: today's move for the stock you're worried about, and today's move for the index (the S&P 500 or the Nasdaq-100).

Step 2

Stressed, or broken?

When the whole market is down, your stock is probably being carried along with it. That's stressed. Broken is when the business itself has changed. Both show up as the same red number, and they mean opposite things.

SignalLooks stressedLooks broken
Revenue fallingCyclical, hitting the whole sectorSpecific to this company, and structural
Margins squeezedInput costs, temporaryPricing power lost for good
Management's toneCautious, keeping options openDesperate, changing the strategy
Competitive positionUnchanged or improvingEroding to competitors

Did the company itself report anything this week? Earnings, guidance, a filing, a change in management?

Step 3

What you wrote

The reason you own it, in your own words, from a day when you weren't scared.

Your sell triggers

Triggers are about the business, never the price. A trigger: revenue shrinks three quarters in a row. Not a trigger: the price falls another 20%.

Has one of these actually happened? Not "does it feel like it." Has it happened?

Step 4

I was wrong about holding this if…

One sentence, with a number in it and something you could go and look up. "If the company does badly" is a mood, not a sentence, and you can't check a mood.

Step 5

Know your worst case

Fear grows in the dark. Put plans on it while you can still think. Drops of 30% to 50% have happened to the whole market, and to excellent companies, more than once, and getting back has sometimes taken a year or two.

If the 50% row is something you truly couldn't live through, this position may be too large for you. That's a problem to fix on a calm day, not today.

Step 6

Say it out loud

Putting the fear into words, and checking it against what you wrote, breaks the loop. Answer whichever of these you want. It stays on this device.

Before you close this

The 24-hour rule

On the day of a big drop, you don't decide anything. Write down what you're tempted to do and why, then wait one full day. If the reason is still true tomorrow after the close, with the news read, it may be a real reason. If it was mostly fear, it will look different.

The same rule guards against the opposite mistake: going all in because something "looks cheap" in the middle of a panic.

Your writing

Saved in this browser only. Clearing your browser data erases it, so copy it somewhere safe now and then.

Education only. This page never tells you to buy, sell or hold anything, and it makes no predictions. The only calculation it does is compare the two numbers you type. Nothing you write leaves this device. Outgrowth Investing

Today's answer